SELECTING THE OPTIMAL BUSINESS ENTITY FORM....
Selecting the best form of business is a key business decision, that should be considered thoughtfully and with professional advice. O'Hara Business Strategies would be happy to help you walk through this process whether starting a new business or at a point of transition.
The following seven general areas of concern should be considered when selecting the right entity:
ELECTIONS / REGULATIONS - The S Corporation requires federal election on Form 2553. Other entities are governed. created by state statute. Depending on elections made by a limited liability company (LLC) and the number of members, the IRS will treat an LLC either as a corporation, partnership, or as part of the owner’s tax return (a disregarded entity”). See the following link for more information on IRS elections for LLCs:
http://www.irs.gov/Individuals/Self-Employed/LLC-Filing-as-a-Corporation-or-Partnership
CAPITALIZATION
The amount of capital that can be raised varies among the business entities. A sole proprietorship is limited to capital infusions and debt raised by the owner. Partnerships are the same except that the pool of capital is increased by the number and capability of the partners. Corporations offer still more options including selling stock or issuing bonds.
ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN
As far as administrative burden, the least burden generally falls to a proprietorship while corporations have the greatest burden. Corporations have to file an articles of incorporation, they need by-laws, file tax returns distinct from the shareholders, hold annual meetings and so forth. Partnerships also can be complex due to the potential for disagreement among partners and the need to plan for a partner's death or withdrawl from the partnership.
LIABILITY
For liability considerations, a sole proprietorship's owner is responsible for the business' liabilities while a LLC, S corporation and corporation limit such liability. In a general partnership, each partner can bind the partnership and the other partners by his/her actions so it can be riskier, from a liability perspective, than a proprietorship.
MANAGEMENT/ CONTROL
Proprietorships again offer simplicity, flexibility and control. However, they are limited in terms of management resources to the skills/ abilities of the owner. Partnerships and corporations, by their increased numbers involved in management, offer more expertise. However, the downside is the potential for increased strife among partners or shareholders.
CONTINUITY & TRANSFERABILITY OF OWNERSHIP
Proprietorships are not a legal entity so they don't continue after the death of the owner. The assets of the business, not the business itself, are then sold. Partnerships are also of limited duration and it is dissolves upon the death or withdrawl of a partner. Corporations, a legal entity, have an indefinite life. Transferability is, in theory possible, but in practice it may be limited due to a lack of a ready market for willing new shareholders.
TAX CONSIDERATIONS
There are a variety of tax issues that come into play when choosing a legal form of entity such as compensation, self-employment tax, taxable years, tax rates and fringe benefits. One issue in particular, as an example, is that all net income is treated as compensation for a proprietor and subject to self-employment tax. The limited liability company has gained favor recently. However, it should be noted that compared to an S corporation, the LLC also requires net income from the business to pass through as compensation, making all net income subject to self-employment tax. On the other hand, in a S corp, a reasonable amount of net income must be considered compensation to shareholders involved in management, and subject to self-income tax, but the remaining net income is passed through to the owner's Schedule E, not subject to self-employment tax.
Again, the choice of a legal entity can be complex. O'Hara Business Strategies would be glad to help in this area!